A week or so ago I posted this paper I had written for an English composition class I took in 1994. That entry drew such little attention I figured why not do it again? So, here's yet another paper from that same class.
The idea behind this paper will become painfully evident as you read through it, the actual assignment, however, was for the class to write a narrative paper. As is all to usual in my case, I couldn't think of one single idea to write on, so I instead wrote about my struggle to find a suitable topic.
Here's how it went....
I woke up this morning, the thought of writing a paper for my English class hanging over my head like some wispy remnant of last night's dream. In that dream, the paper came due, and I came to class empty handed. When the time to read my paper arrived, I searched for it frantically while an impatient class waited. Being the last person called on; the class would not be adjourned until I finished. When it became obvious that I had no paper to read, the dream class turned on me like a pack of wolves, and I awoke with a start. This nightmare motivated me to put some serious thought into what I should write, so I got out of bed, put on my favorite white robe, grabbed a cigarette, and headed for the front porch.I sat in the porch swing, looking out over the lawn, and lit my cigarette. I watched it as it slowly burned, thin threads of smoke gently freeing themselves from its tip. I brought the end to my lips, and slowly inhaled the first real drag of the day. I could feel the fine smoke as it gently burned my throat and filled my lungs. I held the smoke there for just a moment, then slowly pushed it out of my chest, watching the billowing cloud it formed in front of me. The morning air was deathly still, the ocean breeze lying in wait somewhere over the Pacific, so my cloud of nicotine just hung innocently in the sunlight, folding over on itself repeatedly as it slowly drifted away. Even though the first days' cigarette relaxed me, it didn't help me clear my mind, and I still felt some anxiety in not being able to come up with a topic for my paper.
I took another hit off the cigarette, and shifted my glance out over the lawn. A shimmering spider's web caught my eye, gently swaying back and forth between the branches of the rose bush that supported it. Suddenly, the web jerked violently, tugging so hard on its small moorings that it shook the branches attached to them. I looked closer, and noticed a butterfly struggling to free itself from the spider's trap. Possessing the soft heart that I do, I extinguished my cigarette, and set off across the lawn to save the unfortunate creature from its inevitable fate.
Approaching the web, I saw no other indication of the spider, so I swiftly scooped the butterfly from the web, and watched it fly across the yard, trailing a small portion of the web behind it like a tiny kite with a broken string. The piece of web proved to be too heavy for the butterfly however, and he only made it a few yards before coming to rest in the soft grass of the yard. I walked over to where it landed, picked it up by its wings, and disconnected the fragment of web from its legs. I released the butterfly into the air, and watched as he flitted away, presumably in search of a flower that would provide him with life giving nectar.
I tightened the belt of my robe, and returned to my place at the porch swing. The longer I sat there, the more I contemplated the metaphor of the butterfly, how it struggled in vain to free itself, the same way my thoughts now struggled against the web that seemed to invade my mind. If I could find a way to free my thoughts, then I would survive another day in class, just like the butterfly would live to find another flower. I went back inside the house, and made myself breakfast. Perhaps while I ate, I might succeed in plucking my mind from the web so that it might be free to find a new flower of inspiration.
We were required to read our paper's out loud in class, and when I finished reading mine I looked to the teacher fearing what comments she might have for me. She was notoriously brutal with her critiques, so much so I think she could even bring Simon Cowell to tears.
My teacher just stared at me for a moment, and then she finally let me have it.
She said that most every semester, when she assigns the narrative paper to her class, at least one student writes about how he or she labored over a topic for their paper. She said, "Those papers are without exception among the worst, and I hate them with a passion". My heart sank, and I felt myself go flush. "However", she continued, "Your paper was among the best this semester."
To say I was releieved would be an understatement.
Posted by Jeff at February 28, 2008 5:59 PMI can certainly see why she felt that way. It was a great example of comparison thinking with a touch of imagination that would grab and hold your reader--making him/her forget it was a narrative paper.
I'll go back and read the other one more carefully!
Posted by: momma at March 2, 2008 6:18 AM